{ "personId": "sl-3479", "uid": "SL-3479", "name": "瓦西里·威廉姆斯", "version": "V2研究贡献账", "updatedAt": "2026-09-15", "formula": { "q": "Q = 10^(M/2) − 1", "light": "Lᵢ = aᵢ × Qᵢ", "total": "L = Σ Lᵢ", "score": "S = 2 × log₁₀(1 + L)" }, "scopeNote": "本轮当前已列3项有限研究账；M与归功份额为可修订判断。未覆盖内容和未核清的负面作用不按零处理，具体缺口见逐项说明。", "exclusions": [ { "id": "WILLIAMS-SOVIET-AGRICULTURAL-POLICY-IMPLEMENTATION", "title": "草田制在苏联农业政策中的推广与实际农民损益", "reason": "现有来源只证理论、建议和普遍化错误，未闭合强制政策、地区执行、产量、生计及个人决策因果；不能把全国采用当正成果，也不能凭后见之明虚构净损失。" }, { "id": "WILLIAMS-TEACHING-RECTORSHIP-AND-TEXTBOOKS", "title": "农业教学、校长任期与教材服务", "reason": "理论通过课程与著作传播已消费进理论点；校长职位本身不计成果，尚无独立课程制度或教材终态的具体证据。" }, { "id": "WILLIAMS-PALEOCLIMATE-GLACIATION-THEORY", "title": "古气候与冰川理论", "reason": "大百科/农业百科只概述其错误和图式化，未给原命题与知识增量，不能以著作数量设点。" } ], "items": [ { "id": "OUT-SL3479-1894-1939-AGRONOMIC-SOIL-FORMATION-FERTILITY-THEORY", "title": "生物循环、土壤形成与肥力结构的农艺土壤理论", "year": "1894–1939", "summary": "把生物过程、物质小循环、土壤结构与农业肥力组织成一个面向农艺的统一解释框架，并提出冲积土分类、腐殖质形成等具体命题。", "mReason": "M5.3是对有实质理论组织力但含显著错误的混合知识终态的净评估。俄罗斯大百科明确同时记录其小循环、冲积土与腐殖质贡献，以及结构绝对化、低估矿肥和区域概括错误；因此不是先截取正确部分再评分，也不因资料不完整机械扣值。", "aReason": "Williams .40，试验/数据团队 .12，明确前史 .20，直接机构链 .08，同期研究协作者 .08，未解析 .12。", "sources": [ { "label": "原始资料与机构史", "url": "https://old.bigenc.ru/agriculture/text/1914412" }, { "label": "原始资料与机构史", "url": "https://enu.org.ua/use/v-use/vilyams-vasyl-robertovych" } ], "missing": "原著命题及实验数据未逐篇抽样，冲积土与腐殖质子命题边界仍为百科级暂估。；其批评者与同行在生前理论修订中的直接输入尚未闭合。", "status": "缺证暂估", "overlapNote": "1894–1939围绕土壤形成、生物因素、小生物循环、腐殖质与土壤结构/肥力关系形成的农艺土壤理论。完整纳入其把结构绝对化、低估矿质肥料、忽略地理区差异等错误；排除后世全部土壤科学、草田农业制度实施及未核气候理论。", "M": "5.3", "budget": [ { "actor": "瓦西里·威廉姆斯", "actorId": "SL-3479", "type": "PERSON", "share": "0.4" }, { "actor": "威廉斯土壤研究、实验与数据团队", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::WILLIAMS-SOIL-RESEARCH-EXPERIMENT-AND-DATA-TEAM", "type": "TEAM", "share": "0.12" }, { "actor": "道库恰耶夫、科斯特切夫与农学土壤学前驱", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::DOKUCHAEV-KOSTYCHEV-AND-AGRONOMIC-SOIL-SCIENCE-PREDECESSORS", "type": "PREDECESSOR_POOL", "share": "0.2" }, { "actor": "季米里亚泽夫学院土壤研究与出版链", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::TIMIRYAZEV-ACADEMY-SOIL-RESEARCH-AND-PUBLICATION-CHAIN", "type": "INSTITUTION", "share": "0.08" }, { "actor": "同期土壤与农学概念及编辑合作者", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::CONTEMPORARY-SOIL-AND-AGRONOMY-CONCEPTUAL-AND-EDITORIAL-COLLABORATORS", "type": "TEAM", "share": "0.08" }, { "actor": "待核定的威廉斯土壤理论贡献", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::UNRESOLVED-WILLIAMS-SOIL-THEORY-ATTRIBUTION", "type": "UNALLOCATED", "share": "0.12" } ], "share": "0.4", "exactLight": "178.2734368603852474225002097277506465509200714432058272806689409310473691365100639551462646594492877", "light": "178.273437", "standaloneScore": "4.51", "lightSharePercent": "51.4849" }, { "id": "OUT-SL3479-1920-1939-GRASS-FIELD-MIXED-FARMING-SYSTEM", "title": "草田轮作与混合农业制度建议", "year": "20世纪前半叶", "summary": "把草地、畜牧、轮作与土壤结构恢复组织成系统农业重建方案，并推动其进入大规模农业讨论。", "mReason": "M4.9评原始建议整体：既包含草地轮作与混合农业在适合条件下的实用增量，也包含Williams本人把它普遍化、低估矿质营养和地区差异所降低的建议质量。排除的是尚未核实的全国执行事实，不是把错误部分从成果中切走。", "aReason": "Williams .42，试验团队 .12，草地轮作/混合农业前史 .25，传播机构 .06，同期协作者 .05，未解析 .10。", "sources": [ { "label": "原始资料与机构史", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/134962c0" }, { "label": "原始资料与机构史", "url": "https://old.bigenc.ru/agriculture/text/1914412" }, { "label": "原始资料与机构史", "url": "https://riorpub.ru/en/nauka/article/70994/view" } ], "missing": "具体地区试验、推广强制性、农民反馈和产量损益未核。；草田制度与传统草地轮作之间的具体技术差分仍需原著。", "status": "缺证暂估", "overlapNote": "20世纪前半叶提出并传播的完整草田农业建议：定期耕地复草、草地与畜牧居重要位置的混合农业制度，以及把该方案普遍推广到不同生态区的主张。评价同时纳入其在适合条件下的可用残余和忽视地区、施肥与耕作差异的普遍化错误；只因缺实施证据而排除全苏实际产量、生计、政策服从和后世收益，绝不截去方案自身错误。", "M": "4.9", "budget": [ { "actor": "瓦西里·威廉姆斯", "actorId": "SL-3479", "type": "PERSON", "share": "0.42" }, { "actor": "威廉斯草地与轮作实验团队", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::WILLIAMS-GRASSLAND-AND-CROP-ROTATION-EXPERIMENT-TEAM", "type": "TEAM", "share": "0.12" }, { "actor": "草场、混合畜牧与轮作前驱", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::GRASS-LEY-MIXED-HUSBANDRY-AND-CROP-ROTATION-PREDECESSORS", "type": "PREDECESSOR_POOL", "share": "0.25" }, { "actor": "威廉斯同期农学出版与推广链", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::WILLIAMS-CONTEMPORARY-AGRONOMIC-PUBLICATION-AND-EXTENSION-CHAIN", "type": "INSTITUTION", "share": "0.06" }, { "actor": "同期草田制概念及编辑合作者", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::CONTEMPORARY-GRASSLAND-SYSTEM-CONCEPTUAL-AND-EDITORIAL-COLLABORATORS", "type": "TEAM", "share": "0.05" }, { "actor": "待核定的威廉斯草田制贡献", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::UNRESOLVED-WILLIAMS-GRASS-FIELD-SYSTEM-ATTRIBUTION", "type": "UNALLOCATED", "share": "0.1" } ], "share": "0.42", "exactLight": "117.9520831131070604022807953645146501846878305183800681235242705083776918817478760652816414968200630", "light": "117.952083", "standaloneScore": "4.15", "lightSharePercent": "34.0643" }, { "id": "OUT-SL3479-1900-1939-MEADOW-RESEARCH-INFRASTRUCTURE-HERBARIUM", "title": "草地植物收藏、试验站与草地研究机构建设", "year": "20世纪前半叶", "summary": "为草地植物、饲料与土壤研究建立收藏、试验与持续机构载体，使理论之外存在可保存和复查的材料基础。", "mReason": "M4.8按大百科明确列出的标本收藏、育种站与草地研究机构实际建设暂估，价值来自可持续科学材料和设施，而非校长职位或机构冠名。", "aReason": "Williams .20，建站/收藏共同团队 .27，采集保管研究团队 .20，前史 .10，同期机构 .13，未解析 .10。", "sources": [ { "label": "原始资料与机构史", "url": "https://old.bigenc.ru/agriculture/text/1914412" } ], "missing": "俄罗斯大百科支持机构、育种站和标本收藏存在，但不支持1904这一精确起始年；建站共同者、各项目具体年份与现存收藏目录仍待机构档案。；茶园等另列建设是否形成独立可持续科学终态尚未核，未并入本点。", "status": "缺证暂估", "overlapNote": "20世纪前半叶至1939年的草地植物收藏、育种站与草地研究机构建设。排除后世机构论文、荣誉冠名和已在其他条目计入的草田理论；各设施创建年份待机构档案核定。", "M": "4.8", "budget": [ { "actor": "瓦西里·威廉姆斯", "actorId": "SL-3479", "type": "PERSON", "share": "0.2" }, { "actor": "草地研究所、育种站与标本馆创办团队", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::MEADOW-INSTITUTE-BREEDING-STATION-AND-HERBARIUM-FOUNDING-TEAM", "type": "TEAM", "share": "0.27" }, { "actor": "草地植物采集、保管与研究人员", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::MEADOW-PLANT-COLLECTORS-CURATORS-AND-RESEARCHERS", "type": "TEAM", "share": "0.2" }, { "actor": "俄国农业研究站与植物收藏前驱", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::RUSSIAN-AGRICULTURAL-RESEARCH-STATIONS-AND-BOTANICAL-COLLECTION-PREDECESSORS", "type": "PREDECESSOR_POOL", "share": "0.1" }, { "actor": "同期草地研究机构链", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::CONTEMPORARY-MEADOW-RESEARCH-INSTITUTIONAL-CHAIN", "type": "INSTITUTION", "share": "0.13" }, { "actor": "待核定的威廉斯草地研究设施贡献", "actorId": "VASILY-WILLIAMS::UNRESOLVED-WILLIAMS-MEADOW-INFRASTRUCTURE-ATTRIBUTION", "type": "UNALLOCATED", "share": "0.1" } ], "share": "0.2", "exactLight": "50.03772863019160222170064135598654788317036201564950857359776841816486495447122616907702017755593918", "light": "50.037729", "standaloneScore": "3.42", "lightSharePercent": "14.4508" } ], "exactTotalLight": "346.2632486036839100464816464482518446187782639772354039777909798575899259727291661895049263338252899", "totalLight": "346.263249", "exactScore": "5.081317647397930235199888644847807239039243921796655255715251228802628701666098521169304058311615332", "displayScore": "5.08", "provisionalCount": 3, "provenance": { "releaseId": "research-200-20260914", "baselineLedgerSha256": "8bdd406b3e20ae22357644499e622922c670ff11010df0478c70c23b38902108", "c24DeltaSha256": "b0b96144d1d3397e54a61c3d706ff2da5920fe7617e3bef50407149cb97d9d62", "generatorSha256": "25de659e9852503508e7c27d8a31773b8da5d6310531b1e3699d18cc94319929" }, "priorScopeNote": "3项已列贡献的研究估分，含3项暂估。账本覆盖有限的主要成果，尚未穷尽生涯。M与归功份额是可修订的评估判断；未覆盖经历和负面影响不按零处理。", "rank": 155 }